[A humble request: If you can, please donate to help me carry on tracing word histories. Thank you.]
The colloquial phrase (as) tight as two coats of paint, also tighter than two coats of paint, means: extremely tight—in particular in the following two senses of the adjective tight:
– of a competition: closely contested;
– of a person: unwilling to part with money.
This phrase occurs, for example, in the following from the column Quote, unquote, published in the Rossendale Free Press (Rawtenstall, Lancashire, England) of Friday 1st December 1995 [page 33, column 4]:
Tighter than two coats of paint.
Rocker Ronnie Wood 1 describing multi-millionaire singer Rod Stewart 2 who boasted that he’d never paid for a pint in nine years at his local pub and asked: “Do Ya Think I’m Stingy”?
1 Ronald Wood (born 1947) is a British rock musician.
2 Roderick Stewart (born 1945) is a British singer and songwriter.
The phrase (as) tight as two coats of paint, also tighter than two coats of paint, refers to two layers of paint which, applied one after the other onto a surface, form one whole protecting that surface.
These are, in chronological order, the earliest occurrences of this phrase that I have found:
1-: From the column Sounding Off, by Henry Hornsby, The Lexington Leader’s sports editor, published in The Lexington Leader (Lexington, Kentucky, USA) of Thursday 12th October 1944 [page 6, column 1]:
THE KENTUCKY-GEORGIA GAME Friday night at Athens will be the fourth gridiron encounter between the two schools, each team boasting one victory and a tie. Each battle has been as tight as two coats of paint, with the Wildcats enjoying a slight edge in the points column.
2-: From an account of the basketball match between the Purple Raiders and the Kaukauna Ghosts that was played on Saturday 25th January 1958 at Kaukauna, in Wisconsin—account published in the Two Rivers Reporter (Two Rivers, Wisconsin, USA) of Monday 27th January 1958 [page M-9, column 2]:
Kaukauna had their troubles. They weren’t getting the shots, the Raider press was as tight as two coats of paint. They did settle for free throws.
3-: From No stone unturned, a short story by A. R. James, published in the Evening News (London, England) of Monday 27th March 1972 [page 2, column 6]:
“A coffin not required for one funeral, comes in handy for another, but a headstone is more personal.
“Not an item you could put in an end of season clearance sale.
“So Wilby thought to save expense by using a piece of spoiled stone.”
“But how did you know that there was already a wonky inscription on the other side?”
“I didn’t, but I know Wilby. He’s as tight as two coats of paint.”
4-: From Ball hopping just isn’t what it used to be, by Leroy Dieffenbach, published in the Boca Raton News (Boca Raton, Florida, USA) of Sunday 4th January 1976 [page 11, column 2]:
A lone figure, who makes a living with his feet, was wadding, shoulder deep, in one of the country club’s waterholes.
He was a ball hopper, covered with $300 worth of rubber. Golf’s version of the creature from the black lagoon.
He had a disposition to match.
“You guys write everybody up and people think finding golf balls is an easy way to make a living,” Jed (I’ll use Jed because he didn’t want his name used) said. “Forty years ago ball hopping was written up as a weird profession. Now its [sic] one of the most common. I have to come out here everyday or I’d never get anything. Why just the other day I caught an older lady who is a millionaire wadding for balls. That’s why she’s got millions. She’s tighter than two coats of paint.”
5-: From CVC Baseball Race Goes Right Down To The Wire, published in The Evening Telegram (Herkimer-Ilion, New York, USA) of Thursday 25th May 1978 [page 6, column 1]:
When can two races in one league be “tighter than two coats of paint?” When the league is the Central Valley Conference.
The two races are for the league crown and the Class B sectional berth. Tuesday’s CVC games did nothing but tighten both up even more than they had been.